Newsletter

Enter your email here to join our newsletter and receive occasional updates of new content available on the site and more.


 
Ultimate Fantasy Football Strategy
Home About Us Player Rankings Strategy Articles Draft Information Links Contact Us Forums

TwitterFollow us on Twitter  RSS FeedRSS Feed 

Pay What You Want Advice - Start / Sit - Trade - Waivers

Name: E-mail: Type: Scoring:

Question
 
Click here to make a donation

Any question asked before Noon ET on Sunday is guaranteed an answer before 1PM ET
 
 

Rookie Running Backs
(page 2)

Another interesting thing I noticed by looking at rookie running backs is that the higher they were drafted in the NFL Draft, the better they perform compared to their average draft position. Since 2000, there have been 12 running backs drafted in the first 12 picks of the first round and 6 of them performed better than their average draft position in fantasy drafts. The following table compares rookie running backs drafted in the first 12 picks in the NFL Draft with non-rookie running backs who ranked between 14th and 29th in average draft position:

 

Average Draft Position

Average Rank

% Improve

Rookies (top 12 in NFL Draft)

21.1

27.8

50.0%

Non-Rookies (14 to 29)

21.2

32.3

38.6%

Even though the sample for rookies is quite small there is an obvious difference between this data and the one presented earlier. This seems to indicate that rookie running backs drafted in the first 12 picks of the NFL Draft are generally underrated by fantasy managers.

Now that I have shown that rookie running backs drafted in the top 12 picks are undervalued, let’s see how the statistics change for the group of running backs that were not drafted in the top 12. The following table compares the rookie running backs not drafted in the first 12 picks of the NFL Draft with non-rookie running backs that ranked between 21st and 68th in average draft position:

 

Average Draft Position

Average Rank

% Improve

Rookies (non top 12 in NFL Draft)

44.5

57.9

29.0%

Non-Rookies (21 to 68)

44.5

53.7

43.3%

As you can see, this data is completely opposite to the one presented in the previous section. Your chances of making a good pick with a rookie running back are 14.3% lower than they are with a non-rookie running back.

The data presented in this article makes it quite evident that the only rookie running backs that might be worth drafting in your fantasy drafts are ones drafted in the first 12 picks of the NFL Draft. In 2010, C.J. Spiller and Ryan Mathews are the only running backs who were drafted in the first 12 picks. The problem with Mathews is that he’s currently being drafted as the 11th best RB and no rookie RB has ever been drafted this early. Spiller, on the other hand, is being drafted around number 30 and could be worth selecting based on this data.

The four other rookie running backs that you might consider this year are: Jahvid Best, Montario Hardesty, Ben Tate and Toby Gerhart. They are four players that we highly recommend to stay away from unless you can get them about 20 picks after their average draft position.